My first pair of bike shoes had traditional cleats that fit over the back plate of quill pedals. When used with toe clips and straps, those cleats really locked you in. In fact, I fell over a few times when I couldn't get my foot out fast enough. The shoes had thick hard plastic soles and I could hardly feel the pedal. (They were also wicked slippery and I occasionally fell over after getting off the bike.) Eventually, clipless pedals were introduced and all but the grouchiest of retro-grouches breathed a collective sigh of relief.
Yet even when we were no longer wearing cleated bike shoes, we continued to use quill pedals designed for them. It wasn't so bad when I wore thick soled running shoes, or boots. Eventually I learned that thin soled shoes not only improve the bio-mechanics of walking but are also very comfortable. The plates dug into the soles of my new shoes and my feet. That's when I began to suspect that using quill pedals might not be the best strategy. I'm far from the first to figure this out. There were plenty of platform pedals on the market, but most were lower quality.
 |
| Barelli B-10 |
Fortunately there were a couple of notable pedals that met my needs. The British firm
Barelli had the high quality B-10 model which had flat areas to reduce pressure and could be used comfortably without cleats. I think this is one of the best pedal designs ever. The other notable pedal of this type was the
French Lyotard M23 'Marcel Berthet' pedal.
That Lyotard pedal was so great that
White Industries now makes a very high quality copy called the Urban Platform Pedal. I own and like this pedal, but the finish is a little rough and the price is, well... it's $242. Not to be left out, MKS has recently introduced a
less expensive copy (that we currently sell). Curiously the MKS version is also called the Urban Platform Pedal.
 |
| MKS Urban Platform |
Here at VO we'd been selling the
VO Touring Pedal, which offers pretty good support. And now we have the very-well-received
Grand Cru Sabot pedal. We also have the
MKS Lambda pedal and the previously mentioned
MKS Urban Platform.
Given my own experience with pedals, I can't see VO developing any more quill pedals. In fact we're discontinuing a couple of models and they're on sale in the
specials section. We're currently working on another Grand Cru large platform pedal. This one is meant to be used with toe clips or half clips. It'll also have some serious bearings.
Speaking of bearings, I think most pedal bearings are undersized, even those in most MKS pedals, in most Wellgo pedals (the best of the big Taiwan pedal manufacturers and maker of some VO pedals), and in most VP pedals (almost as good as Wellgo in my opinion). They just don't last as long as they should, based on seeing worn out bearing in older pedals we've sold.
 |
Sabot pedal. Three sealed bearing (no bushings),
light weight, rounded pins. It's not just a recycled
BMX pedal. |
So here is the manifesto part; I see a revolution coming in pedals. Cyclists are throwing off the chains (straps) of traditional pedal design. But too many of the current offering are not really designed for serious everyday riders. There is a need for high-end, long lasting, pedals designed for street shoes, even minimalist street shoes, not for stiff-soled bike shoes. They should have big strong bearings, and not bushings or loose balls. There must be models for those who ride with toe clips and dual-sided models (like the Sabot) for those who don't. The struggle will be to make pedals like these at a reasonable price.
